AI Disclosure Labels Don’t Build Trust; Accuracy Does, Markup AI Survey Finds
As CFOs redirect more resources towards AI, marketers face growing pressure to justify their already stagnant budgets and do more with less. But new research from Markup AI finds that AI is creating another challenge for brands: 73% of consumers have noticed brands sound more similar as companies increasingly depend on AI to create content.
As marketers turn to AI to increase content output, the question is whether that content helps their brand stand out. When asked what would make them trust an unfamiliar brand, 53% of respondents chose accuracy. Only 19% chose an AI-use label. Meanwhile, 60% say content that sounds fake, robotic or overly polished makes them skeptical of a brand.
“AI has made it easy to publish more. It hasn’t made it easy to publish well,” said Holly Enneking, vice president of marketing at Markup AI. “Companies all use the same AI tools to create content, so it’s harder to stand out. The company putting its name on the content is responsible for quality, whether a person or AI wrote it.”
Gen Z is most likely to notice similarities across brands
- 50% of Gen Z, 41% of millennials, 26% of Gen X and 16% of baby boomers reported that brands’ content has begun to sound more similar
- 35% of Gen Z, 30% of millennials, 17% of Gen X and 8% of baby boomers have made a decision based on AI-generated information which proved to be inaccurate
- 42% of Gen Z, 31% of millennials, 28% of Gen X and 17% of baby boomers say relevant, authentic and accurate content, regardless of how it was created, does more to build trust
Accuracy and authenticity remain central to consumer trust
The findings also point to a quality gap that an AI-generated disclosure label can’t close. Telling consumers content was created with AI isn’t enough to earn their trust.
- 60% say content that sounds implausible, robotic or overly polished makes them skeptical of a brand
- 81% say accuracy is very or extremely important to trusting branded online content
- 53% selected accuracy as what would make them more likely to trust an unfamiliar brand, compared with 19% who selected an AI-use label
- 73% have noticed brands’ content sounding more similar as companies use AI
- 33% say AI disclosure and high-quality content matter equally in earning their trust, 29% say relevant, authentic and accurate content regardless of how it was created, and 25% say an AI-use label alone
The findings point to three clear opportunities for marketers as they head into 2027:
- Create cornerstone content that is accurate, relevant and distinct to your audience and brand
- Establish content governance processes that ensure AI-generated materials meet brand guidelines and standards before publication
- Maintain a focus on where audiences actually look for value, rather than using AI to increase content volume.
“Today’s content requires a clear message to consumers. And marketers can’t afford to miss the mark anymore,” said Enneking. “It’s only going to get easier to produce content, so having the right governance in place to protect that quality is no longer optional.”
Survey Methodology
Dynata conducted the survey in September and October 2026. The results included 1,000 online responses from adults aged 18+ across the United States.
Last updated: November 18, 2026