Skip to content

73% of Consumers Say Brands Are Starting to Sound the Same

A portrait of Holly, our VP of Marketing. Holly Enneking • November 16, 2026
Long-exposure night sky over desert hills showing circular star trails.

Key takeaways:

  • AI is making brands sound alike. 73.3% of consumers have noticed brands’ content and messaging becoming more similar as AI use grows.
  • Accuracy matters more than AI disclosure alone. 52.6% say clear, accurate information builds trust in unfamiliar brands, compared with 18.6% who prioritize AI disclosure labels.
  • Younger consumers are particularly aware of AI content issues. Half of Gen Z respondents have definitely noticed brands sounding more similar.
  • Content quality is a competitive differentiator. Marketers need to prioritize accuracy, authenticity and a distinctive brand voice—not just faster content production.

New Markup AI research reveals why accuracy, authenticity and a distinctive brand voice matter more than ever in the age of AI.

Your team can create more content than ever before. But can your audience tell the difference between your brand and everyone else’s?

According to our latest research, it’s getting harder for consumers to make that distinction.

In a survey of 1,000 U.S. adults conducted by Dynata, 73.3% said they’ve noticed brands’ content and messaging sounding more similar as companies increasingly use AI. And 59.2% said fake, robotic, or overly polished writing makes them skeptical of a brand.

AI has solved a major challenge for marketers: creating content at scale. But it’s introduced another issue. When everyone has access to the same tools, producing something distinctive becomes harder.

Consumers are noticing.

Accuracy builds more trust than an AI label

As brands debate whether to disclose their use of AI, our research points to a more fundamental concern: Can consumers trust what they’re reading?

When asked what would make them more likely to trust an unfamiliar brand, 52.6% selected clear, accurate information, compared with just 18.6% who selected an AI disclosure label.

80.6% said accuracy is very or extremely important when deciding whether to trust branded content.

That doesn’t mean transparency is irrelevant. In fact, 32.9% said disclosure and high-quality content matter equally. But an AI label doesn’t guarantee that the information is correct, the claims are supported, or the content is relevant.

Transparency tells people how content was created. Quality gives them a reason to trust it.

Younger consumers are noticing first

The generational differences are particularly revealing.

Half of Gen Z respondents said they’ve definitely noticed brands sounding more similar, compared with 41% of Millennials, 26.4% of Gen X, and 15.8% of Baby Boomers.

Younger consumers also reported more experiences making decisions based on AI-generated information they later discovered was inaccurate: 35.1% of Gen Z compared with just 7.9% of Boomers.

The survey doesn’t establish why these differences exist, but the findings suggest that content quality deserves particular attention from marketers trying to connect with younger audiences.

Creating content is easy. Publishing with confidence takes more.

For marketers, the answer isn’t to stop using AI. It’s to stop treating content creation and content quality as the same thing.

AI can generate the first draft, but your team still needs to ensure that what gets published is accurate, relevant, and recognizably your brand.

That requires more than just a style guide languishing in a shared folder. It requires consistent content controls that help teams catch unsupported claims, robotic language, inconsistent terminology, and off-brand messaging before content reaches customers.

At Markup AI, we’re focused on making those controls part of everyday marketing workflows, including through our new HubSpot integration and Content Audit for Marketers.

Because the goal isn’t simply to produce more content. It’s to produce content that’s worth your audience’s attention.

AI has made content creation easier for everyone. Quality is how your brand stands apart.


Markup AI commissioned Dynata to survey 1,000 U.S. adults aged 18 and older in September and October 2026.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Does labeling AI-generated content increase consumer trust?

AI disclosure can contribute to trust, but it isn’t a substitute for content quality. In Markup AI’s survey, 52.6% of consumers selected clear, accurate information as a trust builder for unfamiliar brands, compared with 18.6% who selected AI disclosure labels.

Why are consumers skeptical of AI-generated brand content?

Consumers are concerned about content that feels generic or unreliable. Markup AI’s research found that 59.2% are skeptical of fake, robotic or overly polished writing, while 40.4% identified unsupported claims as a reason for skepticism.

How can marketers maintain content quality when using AI?

Marketers can establish clear brand voice guidelines, verify factual claims and consistently review content for accuracy, relevance and terminology. Applying these standards to both human- and AI-created content helps brands maintain quality as production scales.

Last updated: November 16, 2026

A portrait of Holly, our VP of Marketing.
Holly is a senior marketing leader with nearly two decades of experience helping innovative technology companies find their voice and accelerate growth. As Vice President of Marketing at Markup AI, she is focused on building an AI-native go-to-market strategy that redefines how the company connects with its audience. Before joining Markup AI, Holly held marketing leadership roles at Bolster, Lev, and Return Path, where she built teams and programs that generated hundreds of millions in pipeline. She is also a co-author of Startup CXO (Wiley, 2021) and the co-founder of Indy Marketers, a 501(c)(3) connecting marketing professionals across Indianapolis. Holly is based in Indianapolis, Indiana.

Continue reading

Light streams through a narrow opening in a smooth, orange sandstone slot canyon.

What Is AI Slop, and How Do You Avoid It?

A young woman with long brown hair and bangs smiles at the camera. She is wearing a white t-shirt and a thin necklace, and has a nose ring. The background is plain and light gray. Rachel Harris • November 13, 2026
A trade show booth for Markup AI featuring a large red backdrop with the slogan Catch Issues Before Your Readers Do and a table displaying branded hats, stickers, and a desktop stamping machine.

“The Docs Are Not Alright” and Other Takeaways from LavaCon 2026

A portrait of Holly, our VP of Marketing. Holly Enneking • November 12, 2026
Metal scaffolding surrounding a concrete building under construction.

Signs Your Content Review Process Is Breaking

A young woman with long brown hair and bangs smiles at the camera. She is wearing a white t-shirt and a thin necklace, and has a nose ring. The background is plain and light gray. Rachel Harris • November 11, 2026